America’s Next Top Model: Cycle 8, Episode 5
A tv post by erin, posted on March 28, 2007 at 11:01 pm
“The Girl Who Takes Credit” spoilers below:
Things that happened
This episode opens with Natasha having weird, cat-sound involving phone sex with her husband. Whitney used her Ivy- league education to deduce that Natasha is a mail order bride. Well, I’m glad her parents $40,000 a year is being put to good use here. However it sounds like Natasha’s husband put a baby on the phone, but I’m not sure. If so, then there are TWO moms this cycle? Why isn’t Tyra touting that instead of TWO fat girls?
The ‘lesson’ of this week is how to dress. They meet the director of Elite Model Management and a freakishly tall model give them (horrendous) outfits then asked them why they liked them. When they all went through that, it was a joke on them! Ha! That’s what you get for sucking up! The manager and the model made them change separates, and while their outfits still looks bizarre, apparently they were better.
Back at the house, Renee is all ‘plus sized girls will never be on the cover of Vogue’ and seriously pissed of Whitney and Diana. While, Renee shouldn’t be all righteous and say ‘as much as I want it to happen’– because, if she seriously believed that, she’d be eating Dunkin’ Donuts by the truckload— I agree with her. At least Whitney and Diana shouldn’t be on the cover. They are terrible, terrible models.
The next day, it is challenge time, and the girls get to put their newly learned skills to work! Some male models play on the ‘all models are idiots’ stereotype and pretend to be mannequins and totally fake out Renee. The girls are divided into three groups, where they have to create a SEARS window display which includes them. Sarah, Renee and Dionne are paired together and Dionne is not happy in a way that is delightful! Dionne puts together their outfits while Renee and Sarah make the display. Brittany, Jaslene and Diana are together, and they just suck. I blame Diana. Whitney, Natasha and Jael are together, and they rock it, but since Whitney refuses to listen to Natasha—who pays attention– they get disqualified. Take that, Whitney! The judges are all like “Aww, Whitney, you coulda won, too bad for you” then award Sarah the victory!
Dionne is pissed because Sarah had nothing to do with her own outfit at all and Sarah takes all the credit. In confessional, Renee tries to take the credit too. Good try Renee. The prize is two takes at the photo shoot the next day, which is actually a useful prize.
At the photo shoot, Jay pulls an evil ‘pick an outfit! Nah, you suck! Let’s dress you up like men instead!’ trick on them. Each girl is given a male character. They are one half of a couple in which a drag queen will play their girlfriends. Some of the girls are awkward, some are dull, and some—Natasha, mainly—rock it! Natasha was a hip-hopper and she makes foil for her teeth and learns the dialect and the slang and everything. Pure Rapper’s Delight! (I am so lame.)
Diana really sucks and Jay calls her on it and demands to know why she wants to be America’s Next Top Model. Since Diana is so articulate (remember: “Oh, I don’t know”?) she gives another priceless answer: “Oh, just ‘cause.” If you haven’t figured out Diana is doomed yet, you probably are as bright as Whitney or Natasha.
At panel, Tyra has abandoned her pirate look for a catholic-school girl outfit. It’s not great, but it is an improvement. None of the girls’ photos are great—with the exception of Jaslene because she looks like a boy all the freaking time– and a few truly suck: Jael’s, Whitney’s and Diana’s. Natasha’s is her best yet, as is Dionne’s, and everyone else’s is pretty forgettable. It comes down to—drumroll please!—Diana and Whitney! But Tyra decides to keep Whitney, either because she’s the most likely to punch Renee or because she’s black and educated, which is how Tyra views herself.
Next week: Jael gets thrown in a pool! And the girls get to hang with pseudo-celebrities!
Things that were good
- Dionne bringing it! The more screen time she gets, the more hilarious she is. I’m glad she stepped it up, so we can get more of her hilarious commentary next week!
- Natasha is trying so hard and its so adorable. At first, she drove me bananas, but now, her energy and enthusiasm is rubbing off on me. She loves this, and loves modeling, and– bonus!– she is entertaining!
- Diana going home! Whitney is just as bad at modeling as Diana is, but despite having gone to Dartmouth, the girl cannot keep her mouth shut. I full expect a Renee/Whitney catfight soon.
Things that were not so good
- The editing from the very beginning made it obvious that Natasha was getting called first and that it would be between Diana and Whitney at the end. Try to make it a little more suspenseful, Tyra!
- Sarah not even giving Dionne props for her outfit! “Oh, I love blue. It works with my hair and my eyes and my skin tone.”
- Brittany’s weave is getting worse every week. It looks fake, and– even worse– looks bad.
- Renee being only mildly bitchy tonight. I need her to step up and ensure that the episode will be drama filled and entertaining!
- A SEARS challenge? Seriously? First Goodwill, then a high school, and now Sears? Hell, they could have filmed this entire season in my hometown (Digby, population 2000) instead of Los Angeles and not lost any resources whatsoever.
- That Renee telling the (bitchy) truth about plus- sized models to Whitney not turning into a brawl.
- I’m sick of the kitschy photo shoots. While this one truly proved that Jaslene is a boy, over the past few seasons I feel like Tyra has decided that models transcend fashion and is ignoring the industry where these girls are likely to get their jobs.
Worth watching if….
….you don’t believe me that Natasha can rock urban hip-hop. Her photo shoot was by far the most entertaining segment of the show. Well that, and the weird cat-phone sex she had at the beginning. It was also nice to see the photos be only mediocre, because these girls are still in training and won’t learn anything if Tyra keeps gushing about their awesomeness.
In Five Words
Need Foil? Here’s Some Gum!





luke wrote:
epitomized the ‘weak episodes of this show are still entertaining’ stance i described last week.
i’m looking forward to next week though, that 50 cent moment looked fantastic.
Posted on 29-Mar-07 at 1:44 am | Permalink
Ronda wrote:
I think that though your column had some good points. For the most part I think you’re a hater like Renee. I don’t think that Whitney sucks as a model and I don’t believe Natasha is one of the best. She may be getting there but just because her last couple of shoots were good, doesn’t mean she listens and learns all the time. Every time she is given a criticism, she comes back with something stupid to say instead of just taking it in. Jaslene is the best one there, like it or not. She may be too much on the thin side but she looks nothing like a boy and she rocks in every single last picture she takes. Like it or not African Americans and Latino’s just have that flare lady. And if you call a size 8 (which is the size of Whitney and Diana) fat then you must be an anorexic hater because the only way a size 8 is plus size or “fat” as you call it, is in the model world.
Posted on 30-Mar-07 at 3:00 pm | Permalink
erin wrote:
I don’t think Natasha is one of the best models, but she is one of the most entertaining people on the show. If you look back at my other recaps, you’ll notice I am much harsher on her– and well, everyone as their turn comes–but you have to admit she is improving and that is nice to see.
I don’t really consider Whitney and Diana fat–god knows they are both skinnier than me– I just refer to them as such because, well, in the context of the show and in the world of modeling they are plus-sized. It sucks, but that is how it goes.
Jaslene is an awesome model, I agree. Her strong jaw line is androgynous, which is a great asset in modeling, and the fact her picture in drag turned out so well proves it.
Right now I am rooting for her or Dionne to win.
Thanks for commenting Ronda! I’ll try to be more positive next time, because I do love this show.
Posted on 30-Mar-07 at 8:33 pm | Permalink
Pamela wrote:
Mmm….I personally really liked Brittany’s picture….almost more than Natasha’s, actually! I didn’t like Dionne’s amazingly much though…
Posted on 05-Apr-07 at 2:19 pm | Permalink
Mina wrote:
I liked your column, but it was a bit biased. But it did have some truth in it, so I have to give you props for the humour.
Posted on 06-Apr-07 at 12:50 pm | Permalink
erin wrote:
Thanks Mina!
I’m probably biased, but I figure everyone who watches the show has favorites. I also write these within the hour after the show airs, which probably means I’m not being all that rational (I get overly involved in my tv watching).
I’m not making excuses, I’m still pretty new at this whole thing, and am working on getting better.
Thanks for reading.
Posted on 06-Apr-07 at 1:56 pm | Permalink
America’s Next Top Model: Cycle 8, Mid-Cycle Assessment » BE Something wrote:
[...] season, the photo shoots have been down right cheesy: four faces, gender-swapping, “political statements”, high school stereotypes…..can anyone tell me how these relate to [...]
Posted on 13-Apr-07 at 12:58 am | Permalink
Brittany wrote:
I think it is disgusting that Whitney Cunningham lied throughout the show and better models were cut before they finally saw the light and let her go. I have several friends and a cousin attending Dartmouth. She give it a bad name. She is definately the low class side of Dartmouth, and she is not graduating from Dartmouth! Yet she acts like she is royality. Phony, phony! She is not a size 8–that fat girl is a size 16! She is not beautiful! She gives plus sized models a bad name—LIAR
Posted on 19-Apr-07 at 11:15 pm | Permalink
america s next top model cycle 3 wrote:
[...] America’s Next Top Model: Cycle 8, Episode 5 [...]
Posted on 02-Jan-08 at 5:32 am | Permalink