America’s Next Top Model: Cycle 8, Episode 7
A tv post by erin, posted on April 11, 2007 at 9:41 pm
“The Girl Who Impresses Pedro” spoilers below:
Things that happened
We open with Whitney being all “I gotta step up!” Then they figure out the challenge this week is an acting challenge and then Whitney’s all “I gotta win this challenge.” It’s annoying, but I’ll give this girl props for being competitive. Also, some dude comes along and takes Brittany’s weave out. Now her hair is all cute and model-y instead of looking like a dead raccoon. Hooray! At the challenge the stars come out. Literally. Tia Mowry is there! She’s going to teach the girls about acting! Remember Tia? She was on that show Sister, Sister, which was about twins who are not the Olsens. I wish Mary-Kate and Ashley would guest star on this show. They are appropriate in so many, many ways. They could understand Jael-speak, talk “fashion” with Renee, teach them how to “act” (New York Minute is thespian brilliance) and overall make everyone feel fat and unsuccessful. Anyways, Tia gives the girls hats and they need to ‘work them’. Then, with this newfound skill in hand, they head off to the real challenge.
Inside the theatre Pedro is there! From Napoleon Dynamite. Now that’s an actor with diversity and range. (I’m really beginning to think that I should put everything I’m typing sarcastically in a different font. Then have an advisory warning. It could be like “Choose Your Own Recap!”) The girls are given a script with three model characters and the have to memorize the lines then act out the scenes with Pedro. Whoever is the best wins the challenge!
What follows is a brilliant acting montage, with Whitney thinking she is doing better than she is, Jael being weirder than she is, Jaslene forgetting her lines, Dionne speaking with a Jamaican accent (in her defense, she interviews she had no clue where it came from. Ha! I love this girl so much!), Natasha being bizarre and leaving me wondering if she can’t act or just didn’t understand the challenge. Renee gets a pretty bad edit, but good Pedro reviews and wins the challenge! And she gets to pick a friend! And she chooses Dionne! What the fuck? I’m confused! So is Dionne! The girls win stylized “Vote for Pedro” t-shirts and it’s lame. Even I feel cheated, and I’m only a viewer.
There is also a sub-plot going on here about how Renee is trying to be a better person. While I think this is great for the girls, and great for Renee and great for the house environment, it makes terrible and boring television. While they are all lounging around, lamenting their various issues and non-issues, the doorbell rings! It’s Dionne’s family and Renee’s family! This is a much better prize!
Okay. What follows is yet another reason Dionne rocks. Her mom was shot in a random act of violence and now is confined to a wheelchair for life. Yet, this is the first we ever hear of it. And her mom seems awesome. There. What follows next bothers me. Renee’s baby is absolutely adorable. I thought that the spawn of Satan would be far uglier, but nope! ADORABLE. Also, Renee seems to be a good mom. What the hell is up with this redemption edit?
Natasha’s all sad because she doesn’t get to see her baby. I feel for her, but Natasha: YOU DIDN’T WIN THE CHALLENGE. I’m 99% certain she didn’t get that and just thought Tyra was punishing her.
Natasha is so pissed it carries over to the photo shoot the next day, whose theme is a Payless (hooray! More high fashion!) ad campaign depicting past infamous moments on America’s Next Top Model! First thought: This is laaaaaaaaaame. Post-shoot thought: The clips from past seasons made this shoot so worth it! Also, it’s also nice to hear that some of the past contestants are working as actual models. The girls get their usual criticisms, and nothing is awesome, except Dionne’s gotta make like she’s kissing Kim and Natasha has the flesh eating disease. Despite her emotional turmoil, she stepped up and got the job done like a good model.
At panel, nothing is surprising. Wait, that’s not true. Twiggy looked really pretty. She finally defied Tyra’s thematic outfits and looks like a former supermodel. Whitney and Jael are in the bottom two: Whitney because she can’t translate her awesomeness into photos and Jael because everything that comes out of her mouth is whack. They finally redeem us and send Whitney home.
Next week: It’s international destination time!
Things that were good
- Dionne acting. Dionne’s family. Dionne and her baby’s whack hair. Dionne’s photo shoot. Dionne at panel. Dionne in confessional. I love her, and this she is hilarious. That being said, I don’t think she has what it takes to be a top model. That, and Danielle who won Cycle Six and Dionne have very similar looks, and I think ANTM likes to diversify their winners. However, Dionne is going to go far! I’m gunning for a Brittany/Dionne top two right now.
- The photo shoot premise started off ridiculous, but ended up being modelesque and purposeful: it was about the shoes and the past ANTM girls were there as models, not as pieces of nostalgia. I also liked the comic-book deal at the end, although I’m not exactly how that’s going to fly in their portfolios!
- Jael is like, you know, Jay told her, like, to pose, like Jay, you know, and be soft, and like this, and you know, and down and to work it and like you know, model.
- Renee, who I’ve been convinced is Satan’s girlfriend since the start, is showing she is serious about the competition, even if it means being nice!
- “At Top Model everyday is the best day ever!”
- The elimination was appropriate and timely. Whitney, while surprisingly surprised about getting the boot, was a gracious loser. Although, my personal favorites are the bawling girls, with mascara streaming down their faces, between incoherent sobs, make plans for seeking revenge!
Things that were not so good
- Where did Tyra’s insane friend who teaches acting go this season? Remember how she would make them do hilarious and inane things that were far cooler than wearing silly hats? And how the acting challenge winner used to get a guest spot on a CW tv show? Where has all the beauty — the Caridee-admitting-attempted-suicide, Camille-flat-out-changing-lines, montage-of-how-awful-the-guest-spot-was beauty —that was the acting episode gone?
- Tyra, gypsy is worse than pirate. Just for future reference.
- Dionne’s baby is named Ta’kya. I love Dionne, I’ll forgive her for almost everything. But sending a five year old into kindergarten with “T – A – apostroooooopheeeeee – K – Y – A” is just mean. I don’t think I learned about apostrophes until third grade and it’s not even being used correctly in Ta’Kya!
- The elimination edits have been terrible this season. I really miss the writers and times when I was actually surprised by, but not questioning or protesting, the elimination. Now it’s a challenge to see how early I can pick ‘em.
- Brittany’s not getting enough screen time for me to figure out exactly how annoying she is.
Worth watching if……
……..you, as a young, unwed, unemployed mother, need inspiration to become a model. Or if you want montages of terrible acting and several reminders of back when this show was good, Janice was around, Jay’s hair was brown, and Tyra was slightly more normal. Ah, I miss those years. That being said, this was a decent episode. A forgettable episode, but a decent one.
In Five Words
Dionne Ain’t No Fuckin’ Lesbo!





Meg wrote:
Erin, I love reading your reviews! Most of the time you write about the things I notice when watching ANTM.
While I still love ANTM, this season has been a little lackluster up to this point. It’s enjoyable in that they’re eliminating the girls who can’t cut it, but highly predictable–I’ve called the last 3 eliminations, something I’ve been unable to do in previous seasons.
I’m glad Whitney’s gone, I didn’t think she could cut it, although I wouldn’t have cared if Jael got the axe–I like her, but she gets on my nerves.
I’m not crazy about the shoots they’re doing this season–I liked the Candy Shop and the Death ones, but I agree that they need to get some high fashion/artistic ones in there. I remember all the awesome shoots from past seasons, and these seem so weak!
Posted on 11-Apr-07 at 10:30 pm | Permalink
erin wrote:
Meg! Thanks for the comment!
I agree about the lackluster-ness of this season. I’m beginning to think that Tyra and co have realized this show isn’t about finding a model anymore, it’s about entertainment and bringing in viewers. While it’s fine to change your goals to such, allowing the show to suffer because of it sucks for us.
Jael leaving wouldn’t be a model loss, but would would keep Renee in check? Her smack down last week made me happy. But this episode — yeah — she bugged. Except at panel and her utter incoherence!
Posted on 11-Apr-07 at 10:39 pm | Permalink
luke wrote:
after watching the first three episodes of australia’s next top model in between last week’s and this week’s episodes, this was… underwhelming. if you don’t already, erin, you should give that show a thought. the first two episodes are on youtube, unless they’ve been taken down since yesterday. there are torrents around as well. the girls are much more modelesque, the age limit is younger (16 year olds!), less censoring (listening to dionne this week, i noticed this a lot!), more appropriate modeling shoots (ie. no payless) and the production value is surprisingly comparable. plus this season has paloma, who i would probably give up a kidney for, if she asked. i recommend it!
anyway, not a whole lot to say about this week’s antm. seeing some of the old girls was cool, even though i didn’t start watching until cycle 5. the kim/dionne shoot was particularly good. i really enjoyed brittany with the twins as well, her picture was by far my favourite of the week.
jael has been one of my favourites from the start, but she’s starting to grate a little, i agree. it could just be the editing, but i’m expecting her to be on the way out within the next couple weeks.
Posted on 12-Apr-07 at 1:00 am | Permalink
erin wrote:
I’m pretty sure Jael grates that way all the time, but when one is providing such an interesting mix of hilarity and obnoxiousness, it certainly gives the editors a lot to work with in terms of constructing a specific personality.
Australia’s Next Top Model is beyond hilarious. I love the over-18 and under-18 house rules and laundry punishments.
Paloma is going to provide me with hours of entertainment. Who REFUSES to wear the wardrobe on their first shoot? Then has an anxiety attack? Then gets out of the loser’s task? She is going to make this season for me.
On first look, Alice and Paloma are the front runners,just in terms of looking like a model, but Alice has no confidence and a very bizarre body shape. Maybe Sophie too….
Posted on 12-Apr-07 at 9:11 am | Permalink
luke wrote:
wow, looking back at my last comment: “if you don’t already, erin, you should give that show a thought” may be the weirdest sentence i’ve ever written. multiple typos, but it still sorta made sense in the end?? anyway…
my very favourite thing about the australian version is how they make the losers of the challenge do work for the winners. really rubs it in and just breeds resentment. like, if antm did this, not only would natasha not have seen her own family, she would’ve been making travel plans for dionne’s and renee’s. amazing.
also: alice definitely already looks like a model, moreso than any other girl i’ve seen in any incarnation of top model, but yeah, the no self-confidence thing could kill her. in addition to loving paloma, i’m a fan of steph f. as well. she is so cute and fresh-faced. am i allowed to say these things about a 16 year old? i feel mildly creepy right now. but yeah, a lot of the american girls looks practically haggard compared to the australian ones. i’m definitely looking forward to australia’s next episode more than america’s. not sure how to feel about this.
Posted on 12-Apr-07 at 11:28 am | Permalink
erin wrote:
Well considering she’s going to be a model, it’s practically her job to illicit comments like that out of people like you. So it’s all good.
Now if you said that about someone’s random 16 year old sister, we might have problems.
I also loved how the judges were judging the girls when they arrived at the house. Ha! And also, them giving the girls fairly positive feedback to their face then RIPPING them during deliberations. Too good.
I’m beginning to think I should start a top-model only blog and just recap every episode of every incarnation of this thing.
I’m also extremely excited for Canada’s Next Top Model, Cycle 2, if only to see 1) places I’ve actually been (my sister had her 19th birthday at Plan B AND she knows the rugby team the girls modeled for in cycle 1) and 2) to see how Jay is as a host.
Posted on 12-Apr-07 at 12:12 pm | Permalink
luke wrote:
yeah i met a friend of a friend recently who worked on this season of cntm and said that it was actually really good, and much improved from the first cycle. so i’m looking forward to giving it another shot, even though i couldn’t make it through two episodes in season 1.
Posted on 12-Apr-07 at 12:39 pm | Permalink
Emily wrote:
hey i love this show yaya!!!!
Posted on 17-Apr-07 at 2:35 pm | Permalink
America’s Next Top Model: Cycle 8, Episode 8 » BE Something wrote:
[...] needs to tame her ego. Jael is her bizarre semi-darling, semi-obnoxious self. So, even though Whitney’s gone, nothing [...]
Posted on 18-Apr-07 at 9:50 pm | Permalink